ACM

Communications of the ACM

Home/Magazine Archive/July 2016 (Vol. 59, No. 7)/Upstart Puzzles: Chair Games/Full Text

Last byte

Upstart Puzzles: Chair Games

By Dennis Shasha
Communications of the ACM, July 2016, Vol. 59 No. 7, Page 128
10.1145/2915924
Comments (1)

View as: Print Mobile App ACM Digital Library Full Text (PDF) In the Digital Edition Share:

Chair Games, Figure 1 — The goal is to rearrange the people around the table to be in clockwise alphabetical order, using as few moves as possible, where each move involves moving a person three seats away (in either direction) from the empty chair.

A group of people is sitting around your dinner table with one empty chair. Each person has a name that begins with a different letter: A, B, C ... Because you love puzzles, you ask them to rearrange themselves to end up in alphabetical order in a clockwise fashion, with one empty chair just to the left of the person whose name begins with A. Each move involves one person from one chair to the empty chair k seats away in either direction. The goal is to minimize the number of such moves.

Warm-up. Suppose you start with eight people around the table, with nine chairs. The last name of each person begins with the letter shown, and you are allowed to move a person from one chair to an empty chair three chairs away in either direction (see Figure 1). Can you do it in four moves?

Solution to Warm-Up
C moves from 9 to 6
F moves from 3 to 9
C moves from 6 to 3
F moves from 9 to 6

Now here is a more difficult version of the problem in which the only moves allowed are four seats away, starting with the configuration in Figure 2.

Solution
B moves from 6 to 2
F moves from 1 to 6
A moves from 5 to 1
E moves from 9 to 5

Now try to solve these four related upstart puzzles:

Number of people n and move distance k. Given any number of people n and move distance k, find the minimum number of moves that would create a clockwise sorted order;

Number of people n in a certain arrangement, find best move distance. Given any number of people n, find a move distance k and the minimum number of moves of length k that creates a clockwise sorted order;

Number n of people, one empty chair. Generalize the problem with n people and one empty chair to allow movements of distances k₁, k₂, ..., k_j for some j < n/2; and

Several empty chairs. Generalize the problem further to allow several empty chairs.

Author

Dennis Shasha ([email protected]) is a professor of computer science in the Computer Science Department of the Courant Institute at New York University, New York, as well as the chronicler of his good friend the omniheurist Dr. Ecco.

Footnotes

All are invited to submit solutions and prospective upstart-style puzzles for future columns to [email protected]

Figures

Figure 1. (warm-up). The goal is to rearrange the people around the table to be in clockwise alphabetical order, using as few moves as possible, where each move involves moving a person three seats away (in either direction) from the empty chair.

Figure 2. The goal is again to rearrange the people around the table to be in clockwise alphabetical order, using as few moves as possible, where each move involves moving a person four seats away (in either direction) from the empty chair.

Comments

mtuacm

July 02, 2016 08:52

Maybe I'm missing something, but why can't the first example be solved in two moves?

F from 3 to 6
C from 9 to 3

I noticed that both example solutions have the people moving counter-clockwise only, but the problem says they can move in either direction. Is this just a coincidence? If counter-clockwise movement only is a requirement, then the printed solution to the first problem would be correct.

Displaying 1 comment